The Three victims
I was tasked with running a Gestalt experiment on 3 people of my choice. One of these people has to be a “visual” person-- meaning someone in the art, design or creative fields and the other 2 can be of random choosing. First person I chose was my wife Cherron (of course) because she is always my first choice in anything, I chose my buddy Kevin because he is your average dude and not really design inclined, and lastly Whitney who does interior design as a hobby and really good at it. I tested each of them in private so each subject would not know what to expect. I did test them on both condition options.
After running my Gestalt experiment on my wife and 2 of my friends. What I found is that they didn't see the horse and rider at all until I had to point it out to them, even after going through both conditions. One said, it was exploding confetti, another a bushy tree top, and lastly my wife said it looked like the hawaiian islands in the year 3000 because of all the constant lava flow. The interesting thing that I noticed while my subjects took the experiment is that each person showed their personality when shouting out what they saw in each picture before actually getting to the gestalt portion. For instance, Kevin said, a lot of funny things for each picture, Whitney replied with more of a design aspect, and Cherron had more of a typical girl reaction. All of the replies were amusing as I will post down below.
I personally didn't see the “Horse and Rider” at all when I took the test. Even though it was pointed out to me, it took a few seconds to actually see it (kind of.) In my opinion, this is a horrible example to try and figure out. It is so tough to even see it for a second time even though I know what it is. Knowing this, my subjects were in the same boat, they had a hard time seeing it as well. Maybe now that I know what the Gestalt picture is, I would probably just blurt out “Horse and Rider” and not even try to make it out.
This was a fun experiment to conduct, personality did set each person apart from each other and the replies make it apparent. Read the text version of the test below, hopefully this will make you laugh as much as it did for me..
Test #1/ Condition #1
Subject: Cherron N.
Tester: Isaac
First picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Cherron:Little boy with a yellow shirt
Second Picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Cherron: Wine Bottles
Third Picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Cherron: Kid drowning
Fourth Picture
Isaac: What do you see?
Cherron:Christmas dog treats!
Last Picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Cherron: Tumble Creek house (Our cabin in Cle Elum Wa.)
Gestalt Image:
Isaac: Tell me when you can make out what this picture is?
Cherron:
Step1: No idea
Step2:confetti
Step3:camouflage
Step4:I don't know
Step5:No idea
Step6:Nope
Step7:Hmmm.. Still dunno
Step8:Dunno
Step9:Still nothing
Step10:Can you just tell what it is?
Step11:This is hard.
Step12:.......
Step13:............
Step14:.........
Step15:.............
Step16:..................
Step17:...................
Step18:Oooh, I know, it's the hawaiian islands in the year 3000 after all the constant lava flow makes more islands!
Step19:I give up......
Step20:TELL ME!!!!
Test #1/ Condition #2
Subject: Cherron N.
Tester: Isaac
First picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Cherron:Little oinker! So cute~
Second picture:
Isaac:What do you see?
Cherron: Texas long horn? Right? Wait, is that right?
Third picture:
Isaac:What do you see?
Cherron:Frolicking deer in a field.
Fourth picture:
Isaac:What do you see?
Cherron:Aww, a little lamb-ee!!!
Last picture:
Isaac:What do you see?
Cherron:HAHAHAH a camel with bad teeth..
Gestalt Image:
Isaac: Tell me when you can make out what this picture is?
Cherron:
Step1: Not this again!
Step2:I'm not gonna guess...
Step3:...........
Step4:.........
Step5:..............
Step6:...............
Step7:.................
Step8:..........
Step9:.................
Step10:............
Step11:Nope nothing yet...
Step12:............
Step13:........
Step14:.....................
Step15:.............
Step16:...............
Step17:.......................
Step18:..............
Step19:......................
Step20:Is that the last step? How am I supposed to make sense of this?
Isaac: It is a picture of horse with a rider on top. (I point it out to her)
Cherron: That's stupid, how am I supposed to see that? HAHAHAHA...
Test #2/ Condition #1
Subject: Kevin W.
Tester: Isaac
First picture:
Isaac:What do you see?
Kevin:Small kid running around knocking stuff over
Second picture:
Isaac:What do you see?
Kevin:HAPPY HOUR!!! YEAH!
Third picture:
Isaac:What do you see?
Kevin:Michael Phelps in the early years (Drowning)
Fourth picture:
Isaac:What do you see?
Kevin:Lumps of coal! Bad Dog!
Last picture:
Isaac:What do you see?
Kevin: I gotta pee just looking at this...
Gestalt Image:
Isaac: Tell me when you can make out what this picture is?
Kevin:
Step1:Ummm... Exploding confetti?
Step2:........... Next...
Step3: …. Nope, dunno.
Step4:..........
Step5:..........
Step6:............
Step7:...........
Step8: Holy crap, how many steps are there?
Step9:..............
Step10:............
Step11:...........
Step12:..............
Step13:................
Step14:............
Step15:.............
Step16:...............
Step17:...............
Step18: Really? I have no idea ahahahahah!
Step19:.............
Step20:Is this the last step? What is it? What, another test? Ok...
Test #2/ Condition #2
Subject: Kevin W.
Tester: Isaac
First picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Kevin: Bacon in the making!
Second picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Kevin: Texas A&M? Long horn animal of some sort?
Third picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Kevin:Ohh, discovery channel, where's the lion?
Fourth picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Kevin:Little white..... is that a lamb?
Last picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Kevin:HAHAHAH! Billy Bob dentures!
Gestalt Image:
Isaac: Tell me when you can make out what this picture is?
Kevin:
Step1: (Sigh) This again?...
Step2:Can I just skip to the end?
Step3:............
Step4:.............
Step5:.............
Step6:............
Step7:............
Step8:............
Step9:..............
Step10:.............
Step11: Is this some kind brainwashing tactic or something?
Step12:Gestalt? Is that the name of your brainwashing organization?
Step13:.........
Step14:Hmmmmm...Next...
Step15:Ok so, in the next 5 steps will the picture reveal itself?
Step16:..................
Step17:..................
Step18:................
Step19:................
Step20:Dammit, I still don't know what this is!
Isaac: It is a picture of horse with a rider on top. (I point it out)
Kevin: How the hell do you get that? I just see a bunch of dots.
Test #3/ Condition #1
Subject: Whitney D.
Tester: Isaac
First picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Whitney: Yellow shirt, kid running around.
Second picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Whitney:Wine bottles, waiter opening the front door.
Third picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Whitney:Is that a kid or a dog in the pool?
Fourth picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Whitney:Woo! Can we say, “Cluttered!”
Last picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Whitney:Lush Forest, peaceful..
Gestalt Image:
Isaac: Tell me when you can make out what this picture is?
Whitney:
Step1:Is it a bushy tree top?
Step2:.........
Step3:.........
Step4:...........
Step5:Some sort of Dalmatian spot pattern.
Step6:............
Step7:..........
Step8:..............
Step9:...............
Step10:..............
Step11:.............
Step12:.............
Step13:...............
Step14:.............
Step15:............
Step16:.........
Step17:Hmmm.... What is this?
Step18:.............
Step19:.............
Step20:Oh, is this the last step? What is it?
Test #3/ Condition #2
Subject: Whitney D.
Tester: Isaac
First picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Whitney:Hahahah, aww so cute. Little pig.
Second picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Whitney:Oh wow! Those are some huge horns! I like that brown though.(Talking about the animal's skin)
Third picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Whitney:A running elk?
Fourth picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Whitney:Little lamb sleeping..
Last picture:
Isaac: What do you see?
Whitney:Oh hahahahah, a funny camel smile..
Gestalt Image:
Isaac: Tell me when you can make out what this picture is?
Whitney:
Step1:Hmmm... Ok, I'll get it this time..
Step2:..........
Step3:..........
Step4:...........
Step5:...........
Step6:...........
Step7:.............
Step8:............
Step9:...........
Step10:...........
Step11:Does this go to step 20?
Step12:Hmmmm... Ok, it has to do with the pictures I saw.. (Talking to herself.)
Step13:.........
Step14:...........
Step15:...........
Step16:............
Step17:............
Step18:..........
Step19:I think I know what it is..Wait, maybe...
Step20:Ok, it's a lambs face. (She points it out to me)
Isaac: It is a picture of horse with a rider on top. (I point it out)
Whitney: Ahhh ok I see it now. I would have never guessed that.. That's tough to even see after you pointed it out..